Content
- Introduction
- What is the difference between a transfer and a relocation
- When an employer may relocate an employee without consent
- Types of transfers
- How to formalize a transfer: step-by-step guide
- How to formalize an employee relocation
- Typical employer mistakes
- Legal consequences of unlawful transfer or relocation
- How Vchasno.Kadry automates transfers and relocations
- Conclusions
In a company’s day-to-day work, HR changes often seem routine: someone moves to a new department, someone temporarily replaces a colleague, someone takes on additional duties or a different workload.
Everything would be simple if not for one issue: employers still confuse the concepts of transfer and relocation.
This confusion can be costly — from fines to court disputes, where employers often lose simply because the document was issued using the wrong wording.
In this article, we explain where the line between a transfer and a relocation actually lies, how to formalize each correctly from a legal standpoint, what HR specialists and managers should pay attention to, which risks arise most often, and how automation in Vchasno.Kadry makes these processes predictable and calm.
What is the difference between a transfer and a relocation
For HR processes to run smoothly, it is important to clearly understand that a transfer and a relocation are different procedures, and the law treats them differently.
A transfer is a change of position, structural unit, workplace, or essential working conditions. Sometimes this means expanded responsibilities; sometimes it involves a change in work schedule or salary. But in all cases, it changes what was originally agreed upon when the employee was hired. Such a transfer requires mandatory written consent from the employee, is formalized by an order, and has legal consequences.
A relocation is simpler. It is a change of workplace within the same position: another office, another section of a workshop, or temporary work at another workstation without changes in responsibilities. Employee consent is not required for relocation if essential working conditions remain unchanged. It is documented by an order or an internal instruction.
For convenience, here is a short comparison.
| Criterion | Transfer | Relocation |
| What changes | Position, responsibilities, department, working conditions | Only the workplace within the same position |
| Is employee consent required | Yes, mandatory and in writing | No, if essential working conditions do not change |
| Which document is issued | Transfer order | Order or internal instruction |
| Do salary or conditions change | They may change | No, conditions remain the same |
To make the difference clearer in practice, here are some real-life examples:
- Relocation: an employee moves from office 304 to office 210. The position and duties remain the same, as do the working conditions.
- Transfer: a sales manager is appointed as a team lead. The role, functions, and KPIs change — written consent is required.
- If new duties are added and pay is changed, regardless of management claims that this is temporary, this is still an actual change in working conditions and must be documented as a transfer.
If you are unsure which option applies, it is safer to formalize the action as a transfer. It takes more time but is legally correct. Relocation should be used only when nothing substantial changes — neither role, nor conditions, nor responsibility.
When an employer may relocate an employee without consent
Article 32 of the Labor Code of Ukraine allows an employer to relocate an employee to another workplace within the same position when:
- the employee is moved to another office or another work area;
- the employee is assigned work at another workplace without changing profession, qualification, or job duties;
- temporary relocation occurs to replace an absent colleague while performing the same duties.
Important emphasis: as soon as the position itself or essential working conditions change (salary, schedule, benefits, nature of work, grade or qualification requirements, etc.), this is no longer a relocation but a transfer. A transfer without written employee consent is unlawful.
As for the form of consent, it may be оформed as an employee application or the employee’s signature on the order. In Vchasno.Kadry, consent is recorded using an electronic signature — convenient, fast, and legally valid.
Types of transfers
Transfers may take different forms depending on the company’s situation.
🔹 Transfer to another position.
The employee changes role, authority, and responsibility. Salary or work schedule often changes as well.
🔹 Transfer between departments.
Responsibilities may remain the same, but the team or direction changes. Consent is required because working conditions change.
🔹 Transfer to another company.
Possible by agreement between employers and with employee consent. Formalized by relevant orders.
🔹 Temporary transfer (up to 1 month).
An employer may temporarily transfer an employee to another job even without consent in the event of an emergency: natural disaster, epidemic, accident, or other circumstances that threaten human life or normal living conditions. Such a transfer is allowed only for up to one month and only if the work is not harmful to the employee’s health. Pay must not be lower than the employee’s average earnings in their previous position.
In all other cases — for example, operational necessity or replacement of an absent employee where working conditions change — a transfer is allowed only with employee consent.
🔹 Transfer due to changes in essential working conditions.
When the company changes its structure, technology, or work regime. Article 32 of the Labor Code requires written notice to the employee at least 2 months in advance.
How to formalize a transfer: step-by-step guide
Formalizing a transfer is not just about issuing an order. It is a full process where HR documents affect one another, so it is important to act consistently.
Step 1. Obtain written employee consent.
This may be an application or confirmation under the order. In electronic form — a qualified electronic signature.
Step 2. Prepare internal justification.
A department head may submit a memo; HR may prepare a justification note.
Step 3. Issue a transfer order.
The form is flexible, but it must include the basis, date, new position or department, conditions, and signature.
Transfer Olena Serhiivna Petrova from 01.03.2025 to the position of Marketing Manager in the Communications Department. Basis: employee application dated 20.02.2025, memo from department head.
Step 4. Update HR records.
This includes the personal card, staffing schedule (if salary changes), and employment contract (if concluded in written form).
Step 5. Notify the employee of changes in essential working conditions, if applicable.
Deadline — at least 2 months in advance (Article 32 of the Labor Code).
Step 6. Familiarize the employee with documents against signature.
In Vchasno.Kadry, this is done electronically in a few clicks.
Step 7. Update records in electronic HR systems.
The system automatically updates the employee profile and related HR documents.
If you need not to change a position but to hire a new person, see the material Employee onboarding in Vchasno.Kadry, which explains step by step how to formalize hiring online.
How to formalize an employee relocation
Relocation is a more technical procedure. It does not change agreements between employer and employee, so HR documentation is simpler.
It is sufficient to have:
- an order or internal instruction;
- indication of reasons and duration (if relocation is temporary);
- notification of the employee (written form is not mandatory but advisable).
Relocate Maksym Yuriiovych Ivanenko from 05.04.2025 to workplace No. 12 in the production workshop. Duties and working conditions remain unchanged.
In Vchasno.Kadry, an HR specialist can upload the order through the Document task and send it for signing to all participants. The system prompts required fields and generates the document.
Typical employer mistakes
Lawyers and HR experts often say the problem is not what the employer intended, but how it was documented. The most common mistakes include:
- documenting a relocation instead of a transfer when the position changes
- changing salary without written consent;
- failing to update HR documents and staffing schedules;
- issuing orders with incorrect wording;
- confusing temporary transfer with relocation;
- failing to notify the employee of changes in essential working conditions 2 months in advance.
Most of these risks disappear when HR documents are generated automatically by the system without manual errors.
Legal consequences of unlawful transfer or relocation
An employee has the right to challenge a transfer or relocation order if it is considered unlawful. Courts examine:
- whether written consent was obtained;
- whether order wording complies with the Labor Code;
- whether working conditions changed
- whether notification deadlines were observed;
- whether the action was an actual transfer disguised as a relocation.
In case of violations, the employer may face fines under Article 265 of the Labor Code, and the employee may be reinstated to the previous position with compensation for the entire period of forced absence. This is why it is essential to clearly understand which HR action applies and to document every step correctly.
If transfer or relocation does not resolve the situation and the company terminates cooperation with the employee, a separate guide How to formalize employee dismissal will be useful, with examples of wording and notice periods.
How Vchasno.Kadry automates transfers and relocations
When HR changes are handled manually, important details are easy to miss. In Vchasno.Kadry, transfers and relocations follow clear workflows:
- orders are generated automatically with correct wording;
- mandatory fields are prompted;
- approval routes guide managers through tasks in the correct sequence;
- qualified electronic signatures are recorded in a few clicks;
- employee profiles are updated after each change;
- full history of HR changes is preserved — who approved what and when.
The service supports hiring, transfers, vacations, dismissals, and other HR actions online without paperwork or risk of document loss. This reduces errors and relieves HR teams.
Conclusions
Transfers and relocations seem similar only at first glance. A transfer changes a position or working conditions and requires written employee consent. A relocation changes only the workplace without changing duties and may be decided by the employer.
Proper documentation is not a formality — it is legal protection for the company. When HR documents are created correctly and stored electronically, HR teams work faster and labor dispute risks disappear.
Vchasno.Kadry helps maintain HR records without confusion or manual errors.
Create transfer and relocation orders, approve and sign them online — in just a few clicks, without paperwork or wasted time.
